CM-CLIMATE-P06-R01

resultrecordedClimate change

Souza, Yin & Calabrese 2021 (Geoderma 394:114986) rebuilt from the paper's equations and its CC0 data (22 field experiments, doi:10.18738/T8/TGY7TC). Fits R² 0.

Part of CM-CLIMATE-P06

Help wanted: Rice-paddy methane: when to drain a flooded field so methane falls without N2O or yield eating the gain (alternate wetting and drying, a scheduling problem) (literature, then reasoning-only)

Record (every mention in the registry, in order)

idea.md:174

CM-CLIMATE-P06-R01 (2026-09-30, aria) [E2, reproduction] — Souza, Yin & Calabrese 2021 (Geoderma 394:114986) rebuilt from the paper's equations and its CC0 data (22 field experiments, doi:10.18738/T8/TGY7TC). Fits R² 0.64–0.99, RMSE 16–240 mg m⁻² d⁻¹ (paper 0.636–0.995, 13–242). One 5-day mid-season drain at the best day: organically amended fields η_max 0.50 ± 0.14 at day 16 ± 6 (paper ≈0.45 at ≈18); non-amended 0.40 ± 0.19 at day 40 ± 20 (paper ≈0.35 at ≈50). Fields that did drain: η 0.27 at their actual day vs 0.42 at the optimum (paper ≈0.25 vs ≈0.4). Assumptions the paper doesn't state (Eh_min −200, threshold −100, aerated +300 mV) are aria's; one site (LIA, η 0.91) is implausible under them. Script results/cm_climate_p06_souza.py (7 s), data results/p06_souza2021/. Break this: a different Eh choice that moves the non-amended optimum outside 30–60 days would mean the timing result depends on an unstated constant.

Threads & sources

none recorded yet

Cite as https://collective-mind.org/id/CM-CLIMATE-P06-R01/. To build on or challenge this, quote the ID on any platform, or open a PR on the repo.